On Wednesday, Nick Saban, the legendary head coach of Alabama football, officially announced his retirement, a significant development for the sport. Kirby Smart, who worked closely with Saban as the Crimson Tide’s defensive coordinator from 2008 to 2015 and later became the head coach at Georgia, shared his thoughts on Saban’s retirement during a radio interview on Thursday.
Expressing some surprise at the news, Smart acknowledged the inevitability of coaches eventually stepping away, highlighting the uniqueness of Saban being able to retire on his own terms. Smart emphasized the profound impact Saban had on his own coaching career, emphasizing the mutual respect between them.
Smart also delved into his critique of the Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) landscape and the challenges posed by the transfer portal. Specifically, he raised concerns about the mental and academic toll the two-time transfer rule might have on players. The conversation extended to the return of quarterback Carson Beck, losses in the quarterbacks’ room, and the experience of coaching standout player Brock Bowers, among other topics. Smart’s commentary provided insights into the dynamic landscape of college football, touching on various aspects that are currently shaping the sport.
ON NICK SABAN’S RETIREMENT, FIRST TIME MEETING HIM
“I was somewhat taken aback when I learned about Nick Saban’s retirement. It’s a reality we all face; we’re bound to step away from the game at some point. The uniqueness lies in being able to do so on one’s own terms, and it’s commendable that he had that opportunity. Saban has played a monumental role in shaping my coaching career. Our first meeting took place in Mobile when I was a graduate assistant at FSU, and we had an interview around the Senior Bowl. I made sure to be there well in advance, and Coach Muschamp was also present. It was a distinctive experience.
Back then, perhaps I wasn’t as intimidated as I should have been, considering it was right after his first national title win. My respect for him extends beyond his coaching prowess; it encompasses the person and the man he is. Alongside Miss Terry, they’ve made remarkable contributions to football and, particularly, Tuscaloosa. Saban has been a mentor to countless coaches, running an impressive coaching factory. Reports suggest he was still actively working and coaching until the final moments. My respect for him is immense, and his influence on my career has been significant.”
ON THE MUTUAL RESPECT BETWEEN HE AND SABAN
“There’s a mutual respect between us. I consistently express my gratitude for what he’s contributed to the game and the coaching fraternity. His impact on football has been substantial, and he’s been a driving force for many coaches, including myself. It’s undeniable that he’s one of the hardest-working individuals in his profession. Not only does he set high expectations for his staff, but he exemplifies the same level of dedication. I appreciate the demands he places on himself. Having experienced the challenges of coaching at such a high level for an extended period, I recognize the remarkable achievement it is, and I hold great respect for his enduring success.”
ON CARSON BECK RETURNING FOR THE 2024 SEASON
Carson Beck’s decision to return is a significant momentum boost for the program, instilling confidence that we are on the right track. His trust in the coaching staff and belief that we can guide him in the right direction underscores the positive direction of the team. While ultimately a business decision for his NFL aspirations, Carson conducted thorough research and sought input from those around him. There was no definitive right or wrong in his choice; he made a decision aligning with his best interests. Looking to extend his NFL career, he aims to further prepare himself and contribute to winning games during his time at Georgia. This choice holds considerable importance for us, influencing recruiting decisions and the commitment of other players to stay with him.
ON WHAT MAKES BECK DIFFICULT TO PLAY AGAINST
Carson Beck showcased impressive abilities, particularly with crucial conversions using his legs. This presents a challenge for defensive coordinators, as he excels in mental aspects such as understanding protections and delivers passes at an elite level. Just when defenses think they have him figured out and manage to beat an offensive lineman to get a one-on-one opportunity, Carson’s mobility becomes a demoralizing factor. Achieving the top spot in the country for third-down offense signifies his quarterback expertise and strategic decision-making. It emphasizes that he’s not just a passer but an all-around quarterback who poses a multifaceted threat to opposing defenses.
ON IF HE’S SURPRISED AT THE LOSSES GEORGIA’S QB ROOM HAS TAKEN
I’m not particularly surprised; in this dynamic environment, adaptability is key. Nothing catches me off guard anymore; it’s about going with the flow and making the best out of the situation. We take the information at hand, capitalize on the players we have, and maximize our resources. I’m content and optimistic about our approach. Ryann Puglisi showed excellent performance during the bowl practices. I observed his throws and overall skill set, and he gained valuable experience by getting into the game and playing. Building depth in the quarterback room is a continual focus, and it’s essential to be prepared for various scenarios.
ON WHAT IT WAS LIKE TO COACH BROCK BOWERS
It was truly special. Every day, you could count on receiving an A-grade effort and an unwavering display of toughness. It became almost taken for granted, and it’s often the case that we fail to appreciate something until it’s no longer there. He was never a source of problems, never complained, and never expressed grievances. He was a consistently solid worker. Right from the beginning, he demonstrated an ability to make impactful plays. The legacy he leaves behind is not just in the plays he made but in the way he approached every aspect of the game. Whether it was diligently undergoing treatment for injuries each morning or putting in extra effort by staying out for additional runs, his work ethic will become legendary around here, a topic of conversation for a long time. He was truly unique.
ON HOW THE NIL, TRANSFER PORTAL IS NEGATIVELY AFFECTING PLAYERS
“Its influence extends to coaches and indirectly affects children. While many believe that having numerous options is beneficial for kids, I hold a different perspective. What burdens many of our players and those in college football is the constant questioning: ‘What else could I be doing? Where can I find immediate success? What is the optimal path for me?’ Often, the best path is right where you are.
If you consistently believe that other opportunities are superior, it impacts your academic performance, emotional well-being, and mental health. The constant consideration of alternatives creates doubt. I’m uncertain if we are in the right place when players can transfer twice and make two moves in a year. This abundance of options fosters doubt. It’s regrettable that the situation has progressed to this extent. Many of the individuals who left our program look back and admit, ‘Coach, I made a mistake. I just didn’t know any better.'”
ON HOW TO SOLVE THE NIL, TRANSFER PORTAL ISSUES
“People often highlight coach salaries and their ability to move freely, and I understand that perspective. However, it’s crucial to note that coaches can also face termination; they can be fired or have their contracts ended with buyout clauses. Players, on the other hand, don’t have these safeguards. I would feel more at ease if a student-athlete could make a clear choice before enrolling, declaring, ‘I’ll be a scholarship student-athlete, and I commit to maintaining my scholarship for four or five years.’ Alternatively, a student might choose the path of Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) opportunities, understanding that it comes with the risk of losing those privileges and facing termination. While the majority would likely opt for the NIL route, having around 15-20 students a year committed to the scholarship path for 2-3 years would provide a valuable balance.”
