The attorneys general of Tennessee and Virginia have jointly filed a lawsuit against the NCAA, a day after the UT chancellor expressed criticism towards the organization during its investigation into potential recruiting violations related to NIL rules in football and other sports programs. The lawsuit, submitted in the Eastern District of Tennessee, alleges that the NCAA is unfairly imposing rules that limit athletes’ commercial use of their name, image, and likeness, particularly during a crucial period in the recruiting calendar. Tennessee contends that these restrictive practices breach the Sherman Act, causing harm to the states and the well-being of their athletes, and should be deemed unlawful and restrained.
The preceding day, it was disclosed that the NCAA was looking into the Tennessee football program, as well as other athletic programs and an NIL collective funded by boosters collaborating with athletes. Chancellor Donde Plowman responded by delivering a strongly critical letter to NCAA chief Charlie Baker after school officials engaged with NCAA representatives to discuss the allegations. Plowman argued that leaders in college sports have a responsibility to act in the best interests of students and their families, asserting that the NCAA had failed in providing clear guidelines for doing so. She specifically denounced the NCAA’s “vague and contradictory” memos, emails, and guidance, describing them as a source of “extraordinary chaos.” In essence, Plowman concluded that the NCAA is falling short in its responsibilities.
