This afternoon’s surprise move by the St. Louis Cardinals was the extension of manager Oli Marmol’s contract for two more years, a decision that defied expectations following the team’s disappointing 2023 season, where they endured an uncommonly high loss count of 91 games. Many had speculated that Marmol’s position was precarious, considering the team’s performance, but evidently, he enjoys the support of both the players and the front office, securing his role for the upcoming 2024 season and beyond.
The Cardinals’ decision to extend Marmol’s contract is intriguing, especially given the perceived do-or-die nature of the 2024 season for him. Another poor season would likely have resulted in his dismissal, but this move signals the organization’s confidence in both Marmol and the team’s ability to rebound in the coming year. However, it’s important to note that the extension doesn’t guarantee Marmol’s job security, as seen with Mike Matheny’s premature departure despite a prior extension.
From my perspective, Marmol shouldn’t shoulder the blame for the Cardinals’ struggles in 2023. John Mozeliak has acknowledged fundamental issues with roster composition and the starting rotation that were beyond Marmol’s control. With expected enhancements in pitching depth, I remain optimistic about Marmol’s ability to orchestrate a turnaround in 2024, especially considering his successful leadership during the team’s remarkable 2022 campaign.
While fans may understandably harbor reservations about this decision following the team’s setbacks in 2023, it’s unfair to solely attribute those struggles to Marmol. Player performance and roster construction played significant roles, and there’s no evidence suggesting Marmol lost the support of the clubhouse, contrary to speculation. Given the team’s previous successes under his guidance, I believe Marmol is poised to steer the Cardinals to further achievements in 2024 and beyond, and I endorse the front office’s judgment in extending his contract.
